Hunton Insurance Recovery Blog

Courts nationwide have long held that defense costs incurred by a policyholder are presumed reasonable where an insurer breaches its duty to defend. The North Carolina Business Court in an opinion written by Judge Mark Davis recently adopted this rule under North Carolina law in Murphy-Brown, LLC v. Ace American Insurance Company, 2024 WL 4327353 (N.C.Super. Sep. 25, 2024).

Congratulations, your cracker-jack defense team just won the underlying case. They also just lost your insurance coverage and you now must repay millions of dollars of defense costs. Seem odd? Not according to the Second Circuit in Petroterminal de Panama, S.A. v. Houston Cas. Co., No. 15-2941-cv (2d Cir., Sept. 8, 2016).